5 Used Jeep Owners Recommend You Buy (5 Least Reliable Models Best Avoided)

The Jeep lineup isn’t short of options, with rock-crawling off-roaders like the Wrangler and luxury SUVs like the Grand Cherokee. Jeep also produces compact and affordable SUVs to compete in this hot segment with the Renegade. Every outdoor adventurer dreams of owning a rugged SUV with four-wheel drive. A used Jeep is a great way to get this popular brand and experience unique styling.


Buying a used Jeep is an appealing choice for those who can’t wait to get their hands on the brand appeal of a Jeep because dealer inventory of new cars is limited these days. Considering their performance, interior, safety and design, here are five used Jeeps owners recommend buying and five best to avoid.

10/10 Owner Recommended Purchase: 2003 Jeep Wrangler X

Via: Bilar & Bud

The Jeep Wrangler needs no introduction, as this model has consistently featured on every “best of” list. The Wrangler is an excellent choice for those who want to take their Jeep off the beaten track.

Related: Why you won’t regret buying a Jeep Wrangler in the long run

2003_Jeep_Wrangler_x_2
Via: KBB

The Jeep Wrangler is one of the most popular off-road vehicles on the market, and for good reason. It’s reliable, robust and can handle just about anything you throw at it. The 2003 Jeep Wrangler design is reminiscent of the original Jeeps, with rounded headlights.

9/10 Best to avoid: 2015-2018 Jeep Renegade

2015 Jeep Renegade.
Via: Flickr

The Renegade is the cheapest way to get into Jeep culture. Even with a small package, the Renegade still offers Jeep character. However, it is not always a good idea to buy this used subcompact SUV.

2018 Jeep Renegade
via autotrader.ca

2015 in particular is one of the worst Renegade years. The car had serious engine problems that caused many headaches for the owners. Also, honest previous owners would not recommend this model year due to transmission issues in the 2015 Jeep Renegade.

8/10 Owner Recommended Purchase: 2014 Jeep Wrangler Willys Wheeler Edition

2014 Jeep Wrangler Willys Wheeler JK
Via Wrangler Forums

This special edition model is one of the best Jeep models to buy, as it holds a special place in Jeep history. It gives Jeep enthusiasts a chance to own something special from the used market.

Related: 10 Reasons Off-Road Enthusiasts Should Consider the New Jeep Wrangler Willys 4xe

Gray 2014 Jeep Wrangler Willys Wheeler Special Edition
Via: Netcarshow

The design of the 2014 Jeep Wrangler Willys Wheeler Edition resembles Jeeps made for World War II. Based on the Wrangler Sport body, this baby is unique with its excellent mechanical properties and styling. It received a long list of upgrades to make it more robust and look like the original Willys.

7/10 Best to avoid: 2006-2007 Jeep Liberty

2006 Jeep Liberty SUV
Via: BringaTrailer

According to Consumer Reports, the 2006 and 2007 Jeep Liberty models are the least reliable options on the market. These models also ranked poorly in specific categories, such as engine and transmission problems.

2006 Jeep Liberty SUV
Via: BringaTrailer

It’s important to keep these findings in mind if you’re in the market for a used Jeep Liberty. However, it is also worth noting that there have been significant improvements in the Jeep Liberty in recent years. The newer models are much more reliable and offer a better driving experience.

6/10 Owner Recommended Purchase: 2012 Jeep Grand Cherokee SRT8

2012_Jeep_Grand_Cherokee_SRT-8
Via: Wikimedia Commons

Jeep revamped the Grand Cherokee SRT8 in 2012, resulting in a tanned, rested and ready beast to put the hammer down. The mighty 6.4-liter Hemi V-8 pumps out 470 horsepower when the passing lanes open up.

2012_Jeep_Grand_Cherokee_SRT-8-1
Via: Wikimedia Commons

Despite this car’s incredible performance, it also features Fuel Saver Technology, which is good news for those looking to own a used Jeep. It can only run on four cylinders with the rest idling up to speeds of 82 mph when you’re feeling a little eco-friendly.

Related: This is the most reliable Jeep Grand Cherokee year to buy used

5/10 Best to avoid: 2006 – 2010 Jeep Commander

2007 Jeep Commander SUV
Via: Jeep

The 2006 Jeep Commander is one of the ugliest SUVs. The car came from a Jeep Grand Cherokee with some blown dimensions, some styling changes and a useless third row seat.

2007 Jeep Commander SUV
Via: NetCarShow

Owners get poor fuel economy on these massive units, not to mention the terrible interior dimensions. Although only two inches longer than the Jeep Grand Cherokee from which it came, it was over 400 pounds heavier. Users would be advised to avoid these disastrous SUVs based on their bad experiences.

4/10 Owner Recommended Purchase: 2015 Jeep Grand Cherokee

2015_Jeep_Grand_Cherokee_(WK2_MY15)_SRT_wagon
Via: Commons Wikimedia

World Report and US News named the 2015 Jeep Grand Cherokee second on their list of best off-road SUVs. It had enough power for any terrain you might dream of traversing, and fits the bill of luxury for any road trip, whether it’s taking that special someone on a date or taking a business associate to a meeting.

2015_Jeep_Grand_Cherokee_Limited
Via: Common Wikimedia

The 2016 Grand Cherokee received an updated design, a few more horses for the base model V-6 and better fuel economy; therefore, most owners would recommend owning one.

Related: These are the best third-generation Jeep Grand Cherokee trims to buy used

3/10 Best to avoid: 2008 Jeep Wrangler

2008_Jeep_Wrangler
Via: Wikimedia Commons

The 2008 Jeep Wrangler is one of the most complained about Jeep vehicles. Topping the list are complaints of faulty electrical systems and a poor suspension. Most previous owners have probably encountered problems with airbags and seat belts.

2008 Wrangler
via: mycarboard.com

This used Jeep model is one that previous owners would advise a potential owner to avoid. Some reports indicate that these cars can randomly stop in traffic due to transmission and engine problems.

2/10 Owner Recommended Purchase: 2010 Jeep Wrangler Islander

2010_Jeep_Wrangler_Islander
Via: Wikimedia Commons

The Wrangler Islander marked the return of a trim package last available in 1990. The Islander is a Jeep enthusiast’s ticket to getting a special edition Jeep on the used market. In 2010, this car had additional trim features that saw a price increase of $1,120.

2010_Jeep_Wrangler_Islander
Via: Wikimedia Commons

The model features the “Tiki Bob” decal on the hood and map coordinates representing the location that carry the vehicle’s Islander theme. Side steps and the popular 17-inch wheels fitted with 32-inch tires also come with the trim package.

1/10 Best to Avoid: 2007, ’08, ’12, ’14, ’18 Jeep Compass

Jeep Compass - Front
Via NetCarShow

CarComplaints.com ranks the 2007 Jeep Compass as one of the worst compact SUVs. No surprises there, as this was the first generation of the compass. Spoiler alert, Jeep’s first attempts aren’t always the best.

Red 2009 Jeep Compass
Via Valori Motors

The most common problem with these cars is the control arm, where the bushings break easily. The 2008 version was not a huge improvement, as it had similar issues in addition to engine stall issues. A used 2012 Jeep Compass may have excessive brake wear problems, engine problems, faulty power windows, and other electrical failures.

Leave a Comment